who is Hermoine ?

mewadale

Hi all,

I have read all 7 books and seen movies too. One thing in mind that i want to ask all of you,
If you read all books carefully you will find in all books house elf's and Hermoine are linked with each other.
Even Hermoine expresses her emotions towards house elf oftenly.

Also in Book 7 when Ron cares for house elf to give them a chance to escape, she kisses him.

She has started SPEW.

In movie 3 prof Trelawney says she has a heart of old house made.

OK, now in book 6 in story Hepzibah,
While Riddle was visiting her on behalf of Mr. Burke, she imprudently showed him Hufflepuff's cup and Slytherin's locket. Two days later, she was found dead; poison was found mixed with her cocoa. Riddle was never suspected; Hepzibah's house-elf, Hokey, confessed to the crime.
so i am thinking that house elf Hokey takes rebirth in form of Hermoine Granger and helps harry to destroy Lord Voldemort.

May be J K Rowling will talk about this in encyclopedia.

Wilbo421

LOL, is this a joke?

sectumsempra08

[quote=Wilbo421]LOL, is this a joke? [/quote]

hahahah i know!!

lupinshowl

good thinking mewadale....................but no....................Hermoine, in my opinion...............wants to help house elves win freedom and started SPEW because..................she is muggle and doesn't understand..............Ron wants nothing to do with it cause house elves are born servants and wouldn't want freedom.............they wouldn't know what to do with freedom even if they got it..............like Dobby..............though he was free he still wanted to work 6 days a week..............with lousy pay...........it didn't matter to him..............and Dobby explains it either Goblet of fire or the order of the phoenix...............one of those........don't remember.............

Hermoine is not Hokey reborn...............

HP_addict23

yep , i agree with them , especially with lupinshowl ..

antisnape

Umm

HP_addict23

[quote=antisnape]Umm [/quote]
problem ?

graceofhearts

haha, Hermione is just a lovely person who is against the crulty shown to house elves. She has a consience and she cares about them so she starts SPEW to standup for their rights because they are taken advantage of by wizards & are too afraid or don't want to stand up for themselves... & it is also a fun/ moral aspect of the story...
nice theory though..

antisnape

"problem ?"
No problem. I've just never heard a theory like that. Not quite sure what to think.... but thanks for asking.

golden_hair

Ha Ha. Very funny everyone here would know that Hermione is HERMIONE - and purely so.
Anyone that doesn't think so is either very thick or shouldn't be in this forum.

Rachae Potter

Interesting, I don't think J.K Rowling put any reincarnations in her books, but interesting theory anyway.
and yes as Golden_hair said, Hermione is HERMIONE.

aaron

Lol Rachae why are you bringing back all these dead discussions?

Rachae Potter

I don't notice that they're dead and the topic looks interesting.

Nick

i think rachae is the person who was here today ruining the thread!!!!!

aaron

Well I guess you're right, but this was from October 2009! Are you scrolling through the middle pages of the forum?

Richard

Naw it cant be Rache.....can it?!?
R:,/

Nick

the person who was in here earlier continually changed there name and i think its very funny that old old threads are getting used again espically after the attack earlier today

Richard

Yeah i asked her that,but she hasnt commented she probably left......well i enjoyed her stories lol!!!
R:,)

aaron

I am a pretty good fan fiction writer.

Nick

that just helps prove that she or he might very well have been part of the attack

Rachae Potter

I just went to Page two of the books disscussions

aaron

Aw, the book discussions? We stay with general discussions usually.

Rachae Potter

oh ok
what were you guys talking about

Richard

Yeah stick to the general page,the old threads are useless please!!!
R:,)

Rachae Potter

ok

Richard

Y is the square next to your name white Rache?!!
R;,/

Nick

yea just like the other guy called phantom?

Richard

Really nick?!?
R:,/

Nick

YEA the guy called phantom had something similar to that thingy that rachae had but then he changed his acct and created a username called minion 1 and so on there was like 15 or so minions in here it was complete choas

Richard

Lol thats funny!!!! Well,hell be back im sure.....
R:,)

Nick

i think he/she is back!!! RACHAE!!!

Richard

Shes not defending herself too much.....that worries me:/
R:,/

arunendu

i cant believe that hokey took rebirth
as hermoine because house elf is not
like human being to take rebirth it is a
creature.I dont think hermione is eligible
to start SPEW for elfs because harry knows about house elfs better than her
and he loved dobby the free elf.

Bookworm97

Lol i thought this too XD

Joshie

Some people don't like it when people bump old threads.

Marie_Anette

what iz dis

Richard

DONT BUMP OLD THREADS AHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!

Ash

What's the problem with bumping old threads? Geez. Some of them are better than than some of the shitty threads floating around on the front few pages. Besides, this one gave me a laugh. Just because the OP is long gone, doesn't mean we can't continue the discussion.

Marie_Anette

I'm confused though, what's this about :)) ?
I can't really understand what the op meant to say