Why should I risk this?
People know that I didn't work the last two weeks. I'll post an artwork sketch. You think they won't find who I am?
It's too risky and you don't realise that. I know you need proof but I'm in a very difficult position.
I think I'll do what Emmafan suggested. Keep my mouth shut and not say anything else, as he/she does.
Well, dream_silently, in case you are really genuine, then I do really understand how you feel.
However, just leaving the forum like this won't give you any more credibility. I'd suggest posting the pic at the time you want. If you're really genuine, then there's no need to care about other people's claim.
I second what HalfBloodKing said : ) I'd be pissed too if someone falsely accused me of lying! It's just there was this guy SCOOP for HBP who turned out to be fake, so naturally we are sceptical. It's a shame that some even do such things to where we are hard pressed to even believe someone who's truthful
If you are legit, then please don't leave...and post something that will truly shut up the naysayers! :p
I realize you are potentially risking your job and we appreciate that. Although I also have wondered if WB pays people to leak stuff or they just don't care.
For instance, this guy over on IMDB, Phoenix123, leaked scripts for the previous 2 films and they've gotta know this, but far as I know they haven't fired him yet...I think he said he's working on DH too. But why would they fire? Even if he's doing it under the radar, it's basically just FREE publicity for them!
Speaking of, anyone heard anything from Phoenix or that other guy (something like wild_world or a derivation of that if I recall correctly) on whether they are going to give us some of the script for DH?
Asking for proof is standard practice. Both Phoenix123 and wild_world both provided the evidence needed, and their claims were backed up soon after they did post their spoilers in the form of Trailers and/or screening spoilers. In fact, I'm pretty sure Phoenix coughed up both times he leaked scripts. Different groups of people.
I'm going to come out and say it right now....art work isn't going to fly as proof. Anyone can paint a pretty picture and call it concept art. It's much harder to show something such as a call sheet or something similar, much harder to duplicate. If you continue to evade posting proof, your credibility goes down the drain.
There are a lot of people who want to believe you, myself included, but until rock solid proof is provided, you will be doubted and called a liar. Simple as.
LC: Phoenix said he will have some scripts for us, but he's choosing to wait until filming is wrapped to do so.
shit I'm late!
are you guys still answering questions? doesn't matter if real or not.. lie to me! just kidding
*is ravenclaw tower set in the movie as detailed as in the book?
*is McGonagall actually being spit in her face by the Carrow?
*so no house-elves with knives attacking DE?
*was already filmed king cross part? is Dan naked? lol what about the crying creature?
*how do the trio look like with the cgi aging effect? is there any art concept of that? how do they look to you? any simmilarity to anyone? just say 'hmm, emma look like julia roberts' or something like that lol
I'm going to come out and say it right now....art work isn't going to fly as proof. Anyone can paint a pretty picture and call it concept art. It's much harder to show something such as a call sheet or something similar, much harder to duplicate. If you continue to evade posting proof, your credibility goes down the drain.
There are a lot of people who want to believe you, myself included, but until rock solid proof is provided, you will be doubted and called a liar. Simple as.
Yeah, artwork won't be concrete evidence. And agree with everything else you said...except I don't think he/she should be called a liar.
If you ask me, that's unfair- "innocent until proven guilty", you know? : )
I agree with Emmafan.... i don't believe this dream_silently person at all, yeah i know what proof do i have.... none admittedly ..... but what proof do THEY have..... NONE!
Want to know something else Dream is right on? Did anyone know of the Hogsmeade scene in the winter where they go? Because the leaked trailer shows that, proving it also.
Keet you didn't believe him from the very beginning because of all the accounts created. You thought he'd created all the new accounts by himself and was basically answering himself, which wasn't the case. Your judgement was wrong in that instance, and could be again.
I believe him. Nobody could have typed up all that stuff up just from imagination, and which such consistency, which shows he wasn't just making it up as he goes along. He corrects people too. If he was a fake he would probably just go along with something so that people like his response, and therefore him.
Dream, I hope you're still reading this, because there ARE people that do believe you and would like you to come back. Please think about it, because there will always be haters, but there are people that don't think you are a liar, me included! Please.
Well if he does work in the art department like he says he does then he's already putting his job at risk. I wouldn't risk my job further by telling fans things who only call me a fake anyway.
Well if he does work in the art department like he says he does then he's already putting his job at risk. I wouldn't risk my job further by telling fans things who only call me a fake anyway.
Yeah..... IF he does work in the art dept...... only saying..... theres no proof..... why don't they post something from the art department.....
If he posts something he's been working on and someone finds it then they will know it's him. He should post something else, like a call sheet or a photograph of the script he has.
the picture come from magical menagerie but warner Bros ask them to remove it but the pic make its turn on web ^^
And personnaly i'm like keet i want to believe but like i'm not an child anymore i want that person prove me that he work on the movie but for me he give to much informationa bout to much part of the filming but when we know many team work in the same time on differente scene it 's really hard to believe he know all !
UniversalHarryPotter
aww. well at least we can still see it here. great picture.
and let's just put it this way in terms of the "we want proof" part...
it's acceptable that people did not Entirely believed dreamsilently. some people are naturally sceptical some aren't
however, he already left because he was insulted. the chances of him comming back are in the air. not because he was lying/telling the truth, but most likely because if someone shares something with others, but that other person insults him, the person sharing feels insulted and un appreciated, so they probably wouldn't want to share any more.
now, there are some people in this forum that chose to believe dreamsilently is/was telling the truth, and we want him to continue telling stuff.
however, he is gone. he doesn't seem to be comming back. and acussation about him still fly:
"if you were genuine you wouldn't...." "IF he does work in the art dept...... only saying..... theres no proof"... etc
as long as individual keep making those "I don't believe dreamsilently" statements dreamsilently will never come back to show things because he will keep feeling threaten and mistrusted. and insulted
so we all have to be silent, no more assumptions and give dreamsilently space and opportunity to prove if he is genuine.
because those who don't believe him left it very clear already. no one needs to be kept being remind.
as long as individual keep making those "I don't believe dreamsilently" statements dreamsilently will never come back to show things because he will keep feeling threaten and mistrusted. and insulted
How could anyone feel threatened for sayin i don't believe untill i have proof, i said we'll leave it at that i wasn't gonna say anyting else on the matterof not believing him blah blah, you sound like a broken record
And no- one has insulted him either, asking for proof isn't insulting someone.
Stop making out just because a couple of people don't believe everything they read that we've had a massive affect and that's why he's stopped coming on
I have nothing personal against dream.... just to clear that up!!!
Look he intended to give proof and some of us kept saying he's a liar. Why should he come back?
It's our fault. We should just listen to him, be silent and wait for confirmation.
dream_silently come baaack! PLEASE! I belive in you! and i wanted to ask you about the forest scene with sirius, remus, james, lily and harry (and when harry finds out he's a hocrux). Is it like in the book? (i cry everytime i read it, and i want to cry watching it LOL)
Hey dream, if you ever come back, can you answer this question:
Do the evil ghosts of Harry and Hermione from the Horcrux actually kiss or do they only approach each other as though they're going to? Because I've seen some articles that say they definitely kiss and others that only describe it as an "approach". Which is it?